Blogging The PBS All-American Presidential Forum

I'm honored to join a distinguished and diverse panel of bloggers in covering tomorrow night's presidential debate at Howard University.

Not only do I get a front row seat to history in the making, but I also get to blog about it onsite.


I'm hoping that all of America tunes in for the All-American Presidential Forum on PBS moderated by Tavis Smiley.

The blogger coverage of the debate is coordinated by Media Bloggers Association. Click here for a listing of the invited bloggers--and for an aggregation of their commentaries.

The Opening

Very nice of Smiley to recognize the young people from Memphis who paid for their trip to DC by washing cars. Governor Deval Patrick got a bit of face time for his future run for national office. He's one Massachusetts politician that can go places.

Slow start

We're 26 minutes into the debate and we've only had one question--and that question illicited what sounded like bits from the standard stump speeches.


Such an important topic--education, but it's too broad a question. The candidates are saying they for education and for all sorts of programs. Although I do like that Gravel and Kucinch drew the linkage between the squandering of billions on a bad war and the need to invest in quality education for the nation's children.

I also think that Obama's point that we need to see the country's poor children as our children as a necessary ingredient towards improving educational results is a good one.

I honestly don't know what Hillary offered because she seemed to scream her response.


They're all for health care for everybody, but it was the question on HIV that got the most attention--and laughter.

Biden just said that he spent last summer in the Blaaaack sections of town educating Blaaaack men that it's OK to wear condoms. Really?

Then Biden further embarrassed himself by saying that he and Obama got checked for AIDS.

That revelation prompted Obama to interject that it was he and Michelle (and, I guess, not Obama and Biden) and that they did so as part of a mission to Africa. Very funny.

Does Biden know how silly he sounds?

Economy Disparity

Hillary: Those with the most must contribute to this country. OK.

Biden: blah, blah, blah

Richardson: Give incentives to those companies that invest in the inner city.

Ouch! Smiley just cut-off Richardson and told him he was finished.

That's it! Next question.

Smiley is trying to speed things up and these already over hyped candidates now seem like they're on speed.

Criminal Justice

Dodd wants to end the disparity between between crack cocaine and powder cocaine. Hmmm. Hey, Hillary is for that, too. Biden wrote the drug court legislation and he's introduced legislation to also deal with crack and powder. Richardson somehow squeezed having people join unions.

New Orleans

The question has to do with whether the candidates support a federal law guaranteeing the return of displaced residents? Yes.

This is a hugely important topic: what to do about the people displaced by Katrina? But the candidates just do not have time to give thoughtful answers. Edwards and Obama are for giving the people of New Orleans a role in the rebuilding of the City--as opposed to giving fat contracts to the Bechtel and Haliburtons. OK, interesting idea.


Hillary just mentioned her initiative in NY to create jobs--especially in Upstate NY. She didn't however mention that that initiative has done zippo. Upstate has fewer jobs now than it had before she ran for senate. I'm not trying to pick on he. It's just that I happen to know the facts in this specific instance. Lost of promise, no results.

Edwards: Eliminate tax breaks for companies that export jobs abroad.

Obama: Reinvesting in communities burdened by globalization.

Kucinch: Cancel NAFTA and the WTO.

We're at the last question?


Dodd: US ought to act.

Hillary: No fly zone over the Sudan. Shoot down their planes.

Biden: Stop talking, start acting. Send in American soldiers.

Richardson: Fighting genocide is more important than sports. Don't forget Africa.

Edwards: Make primary education available to 100MM children around the world.

Obama: Trade and invest in Africa.

Kucinch: Make companies stop exploiting Africa.

Gravel: Need moral judgement. And most of the people on this stage don't have moral judgement because of what they've done. Say what?

Obama, Memphis Students Win; Tavis, PBS Lose

Wow, the pacing of the debate was all off.

It started way too leisurely--hugging, posing for photos, mentioning your horoscope sign--and became strangely frenetic.

I liked that the forum lacked the stiff formality typical of most televised debates/forums. Warmth and friendliness are good things. But the pacing was all wrong. Very unfortunate.

In terms of the questions or issues discussed, that was somewhat disappointing as well. I felt that the question were too general--prompting very general responses.

However, most inexcusable was that the questioners failed to ask about the major issues of the day: the War in Iraq, immigration reform and climate change. Why?

In terms of the candidates, we learned very little new about them and their positions--other than that Gravel is a bit of a loony tune. Probably a nice guy, but a loony tune.

The winners?

I don't think anybody won because the format was so bad. Actually, Obama is the winner because he seemed comfortable, didn't yell, didn't insult anybody, looked in command, knew what he was talking about, mentioned his wife and offered a moment of levity.

The children from Memphis.

And Governor Deval Patrick.

The Losers?

The debate format.

Mentioning your horoscope sign.

Tavis Smiley and whomever was directing the debate coverage for failing to properly manage the flow of the forum.


  1. Anonymous6/29/2007

    I watched the debate and I was disappointed on the way Tavis interrupted the candidates. I believe a timer/bell should be used instead of Tavis.
    I believe Hilary responded stongly to all questions and Obama just barely reflected his inexperience in global affairs. I want someone who can win the Whitehouse and not someone only of color. We must see the Big picture.

  2. Anonymous6/29/2007

    That was great! Very well said! I attended the debate last night, and I agree, it was hard to get a thoughtful answer out of any of the candidates when half the time they were talking, Tavis was telling them to STOP talking! It's unfortunate that it ended up being so rushed. I would have loved to hear more from the candidates on each issue.
    ...And yes, I agree with you blogger. Gravel--can we say loco en la cabeza!! He was screaming, "the only way to solve the problem [of lack of education funding for A.A.'s] is to get the drugs out of YOUR neighborhoods!" And, "this war on drugs is what's tearing apart YOUR neighborhoods & YOUR communities!!" Well, uh, newsflash for you Gravel, I never grew up in a drug ridden neighborhood! I grew up in a beautiful city in Bellevue, Washington, where most of the people doing drugs were HIS white, suburban mothers & fathers! (In secret ofcourse!) Now, I agree with Obama in that we need to come together to treat the future youth of America as our own youth, but, I feel like Gravel was just making assumptions that all African Americans are the same and have the same struggles. Which is not correct.
    Anyways, although the show was unsuccessful in format and lacked in depth debate, I enjoyed the wonderful photo opps! (I got one with Hillary and Obama! whoo-hoo!) Hopefully, next time the African American community has a platform to make history, we'll plan more in order to make better use of our time and the great resources available to us.

  3. Anonymous6/29/2007

    I liked the fact that Tavis kept things moving. Having watched the previous debates, I know the candidates do not respond to a timer or a light; thus, someone just has to tell them to to stop talking and Tavis did. Furthermore, none of the debates have allowed for thorough answers because there are so many candidates. The winners for consistently answering the questions asked were Obama, Edwards and Biden. Hilary gave her one, consistent, mainstream media sound bite moment. Unfortunately, mainstream media will do what is always does: use a single moment to anoint her the winner.